Seven Rules for Writing Historical Fiction
By Elizabeth Crook
We grow up being told to "write" what we "know", but history is the
unknown. You have to learn almost everything about a period and the social
customs just to get your characters out of their beds, (or off of their
skins,) and feed them breakfast.
Rule #1: Sweat the Small Stuff.
The authenticity of historical fiction depends on your knowledge and use
of historical detail. It is not enough to say a character walked down the
street. The reader has to be able to see the street, see the conveyances;
he has to smell the smoke from the factories or the sewage in the gutter.
If there are street vendors, he has to know what they're selling. This is
a new world: the reader can't fathom it unless you give him images. These
should be accurate and not recycled from old movies.
Here are two suggestions apart from the usual methods of research.
Rule #2: Dump the Ballast.
- Find experts on the topics you need to learn about. It's easier to
track down someone who knows about sheep ranching in the 1890's or the
origins of the New York subway system, and to call them up when you need
to know about scabies or the early methods of blasting tunnels, than it is
to find, in documents or on the internet, the exact answer to every
question that comes up in the course of writing a book. If you're going to
write a scene involving a train wreck in 1891, get some books on train
wrecks, read enough to know what you're talking about, google the authors
and find out where they work. Call them up and see if they'll talk to you.
Latch on to the friendly ones. "What about the couplers?" you can ask
them, having read enough to know that faulty couplers were a major factor
in train wrecks. "If this is 1891, what kind of couplers would we have?" I
once needed to know about Mormons in Mexico. I googled "Mormons in
Mexico," found a woman who had written a dissertation on a Mormon
settlement near Juarez and tracked her down through the school. She spent
two hours on the phone with me describing vividly the Mormon settlement
that my characters needed to visit. Dozens of experts on a wide range of
topics have generously helped me in similar ways.
- If your story takes place after catalogs were in use, get hold of
reprints of old catalogs. I have an 1895 Montgomery Ward Catalog that has
descriptions of, and prices for, almost every personal item used by people
of that time: hardware, books, stationery, toys, guns, toiletries,
wallpaper, stoves, laundry equipment, harnesses and saddlery -- the list
goes on and on. It represents the lifestyle of that decade.
In order to write authentic historical fiction you must know a period of
time well enough to disappear daily through a wormhole to the past and
arrive at the location of your story. There you must understand the
customs and use the manners perfectly enough to be accepted by people
walking the streets (if there are streets) and to dress yourself, and make
a living. This said, the major trick of writing good historical fiction is
not in compiling research or knowing the details, but in knowing the
details to leave out. Try to avoid overwriting. Keep perspective on what
will interest the reader. Historical fiction writers tend to be overly
conscientious and excited by minutia: if you succumb to excess, and put in
too much detail, then go back later and take some of it out. Think of your
novel as a boat that is about to sink from having too much weight on
board: some of the loved items will have to go. Toss them over with
impunity! Throw them out! If a rare, surprising statistic, or a moving
anecdote, or an obscure reference you saw to an interesting thing that
happened in the county adjacent to the one where your story takes place,
does not advance your plot or provide your reader with important
information about your characters, then it is irrelevant to your story and
must go overboard.
Keep in mind that the care, and time, it took to assemble all that you
have just thrown out has not been wasted. It was necessary to gather these
facts and assess their worth in order to know which ones to save.
Rule # 3: Keep Your Conscience Clean.
If your characters are based on real people and you are using the names,
be reasonably responsible to the originals. You are probably going to have
to fill in a lot of gaps in the historical record: you may know from the
record what a person did and when he did it, but not why. It's the "why"
that defines his character. Ask yourself: Am I getting this right? Am I
getting it close to right? Am I doing this person a disservice?
Rule #4: Resist Judging Your Characters.
We live in the 21st century with certain shared values: our society
disapproves of prejudice and chauvinism and provincialism. But your
characters are people of their own times; allow them to be bigoted or
politically backwards. Don't pass judgment on them, don't apologize for
their mistakes, and don't attempt to make them all into free thinkers who
are ahead of their times. You have to be able to see the story from their
perspective, even if it offends you. If you judge your characters, you
will date your book. Years from now when your own moral sensibilities are
antiquated, your book will be too.
Rule #5: Watch Out for First Person.
I put down three books recently because I was annoyed with the first
person viewpoint, which came across as self-absorbed. Unless you're
writing in the form of letters or journals, make sure any first-person
character has a good reason to be telling his story. People tend not to
like people who notice themselves too much or describe themselves or seem
overly aware of how others perceive them. Anyone relating a story about
himself -- what he said, what he was wearing, what inflection he had in
his voice or what gesture he made as he spoke some pronouncement -- we
dismiss as annoying and self-important. We feel the same about characters.
There are many beautiful books written in first person, but know the
challenge of this before you start out, and be sure to give a credible
reason why your character needs to tell his story and why he deserves an
Rule #6: Don't Get Bogged Down by Back-story.
It is easy to be overly dutiful and bore your readers with too much
background information delivered too soon. There is no surer way to lose
your reader than to answer every question before he wonders about it.
Don't explain everything up front or set things up too thoroughly.
Instead, let your story unfold dramatically. Clarity will emerge
eventually. The trick is to delay telling back-story for as long as
possible. You will find that most of it is never needed. It percolates up
through the real story when the real story gets going.
Rule#7: Anticipate a Long Process.
Historical novels usually take several years to write, as they require
research at every turn. You won't always be able to anticipate what you'll
need to know for a scene, and will constantly have to be returning to your
references. This is entirely different from writing contemporary fiction.
Take, for example, in my part of the world, a trip from Austin, Texas to
the nearby town of San Marcos. If you are going to write a present-day
scene in which your character makes this trip, you will simply need to put
him into a vehicle -- a pickup, or a Volvo -- and head him south for forty
minutes on the flat terrain of interstate 35, passing strip malls and
fields and the town of Buda. He will then take the exit marked "Wonder
World", named for a local cave and visitor's center, and arrive in San
Marcos. The only research needed to write this scene will be to drive the
But if your character takes this journey in 1906, you will have to learn a
few things before starting him out, and learn more things along the way.
First of all, you need to know where the road is, and what's on either
side of it, and what kind of conveyance your character is driving. If it's
a flatbed wagon, what's pulling it -- a horse, a half-lame mule, two
mules? How often do mules need water? How much traffic will there be? Any
cars? What kind of food or luggage do you have along? And what if a wheel
breaks, and you have to fix it, and you cut yourself with a rusty tool --
how do you disinfect the cut? Do you even know about disinfection? When
did people figure out where tetanus came from? And -- assuming that you
eventually make it to San Marcos, what's in San Marcos, anyway? As for the
Wonder World exit -- when was the cave called "Wonder Cave" actually
But here is where the magic comes in: you begin to think, "Wow. The
discovery of Wonder Cave. Now that would make a scene . . ." And then
suddenly you have a story, and a book to write. The only problem, of
course, is that you will soon find out that Wonder Cave was discovered in
1898 instead of 1906, so you will have to move your story back eight years
and find out what sort of vehicles they drove in 1898 and along what road,
and the rest of it, or else joggle the facts and sacrifice credibility in
the name of literary license. Or ditch Wonder Cave.
Writing historical fiction is like trying to get to San Marcos when you
have no car, you don't know where the road is, and you have never in your
life harnessed a half-lame mule to a flatbed wagon.
Assume it is going to be a while before you arrive.
None of these rules, obviously, is iron-clad. I'm sure there is a
brilliant counter-example somewhere for each and every one of them. I hope
you find them useful. Good luck! Happy Travels! God's speed.
Elizabeth Crook is the author of three novels
The Night Journal (Viking),
Promised Lands (Doubleday) and
The Raven's Bride (Doubleday), and has been published in anthologies and
in periodicals such as Texas Monthly, Publisher's Weekly, and the
Southwestern Historical Quarterly. Born in Houston, she has lived in
Texas, Australia, and Washington, D.C, and currently lives in Austin with
her husband and two children. Her website can be found at: